What a mallet is for
A mallet drives a chisel, a carving gouge or a joint together without the damage a steel hammer would do to most Western chisel handles. Many chisel makers are clear about the difference: Lie-Nielsen says its chisels should not be struck with a metal hammer. Wood, leather and urethane heads give a firm blow while sparing the handle.
The three common kinds
| Type | Construction | Job | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joiner’s | A rectangular hardwood head with flat, angled faces on a straight handle | Chopping joints with bench and mortise chisels; knocking joints together | Must be swung so a face lands squarely |
| Carver’s | A round head, turned in wood or moulded in urethane | Driving carving gouges and chisels from any angle | The curved face meets the tool along a line of the curve rather than across a flat face |
| Soft-faced | A head with a leather, urethane or rubber face | Assembling and dismantling joints; gentler blows on chisels | The face yields a little, so the blow is gentler |
- Joiner’s mallets have angled faces for a reason. A mallet swings in an arc, so a face square to the handle meets the tool tilted; Christopher Schwarz explains the angled faces of Blue Spruce’s mallets as a way to hit tools and work with the full face.
- Carver’s mallets are round, so the head presents the same face however it is turned in the hand — useful when attention is on the edge rather than the mallet. Wood is Good describes its urethane heads as gentle on tool handles because they spread the load over a large area.
- Soft faces protect the work. Blue Spruce puts harness leather on one face of its joiner’s mallets, for assembling joinery without marking the wood and for softer blows on chisels.
Weight: force against control
A heavier head delivers more energy for the same swing, so it drives a chisel deeper with fewer blows; a lighter one is easier to control and less tiring for fine work. Makers size their mallets to match. Blue Spruce makes its joiner’s mallet in a small 14–16 oz size for dovetailing, furniture assembly and smaller mortising, and a large 22–24 oz size for large mortise and tenon work; Wood is Good makes carving mallets from 12 to 30 oz.
Head material affects weight as much as size. Blue Spruce infuses its maple heads with resin to increase their density, so a compact head carries more weight.
Head materials
What mallet heads are made of
- Hardwood
- The traditional joiner’s mallet head. It gives a firm blow without the damage a steel hammer does to a Western chisel handle. Blue Spruce infuses maple with resin to make it denser.
- Urethane
- Moulded or cast onto a carving mallet head. Wood is Good describes its urethane heads as spreading the load over a large area of the tool handle.
- Leather
- Fitted as a face on a wooden head. Blue Spruce uses harness leather for assembly and for softer blows on chisels.
- Steel
- Used for Japanese chisels, which are struck with a steel hammer, the gennou. It is not a substitute for a mallet on Western chisels, as described below.
Steel hammers and Japanese chisels
Japanese striking chisels are made to be driven with a steel hammer. Their handles carry a steel hoop at the struck end that takes the force of the blow and stops the wood splitting. Stan Covington, who sells Japanese tools, argues that a hardened steel hammer delivers more energy to a chisel in a more controllable way than any other striker. He describes a wooden or plastic mallet as acceptable, though not necessary, for these chisels.
The same hammer can wreck a Western chisel handle that was not designed for it — Covington says so himself. The rule is the maker’s: Lie-Nielsen, for example, says its chisels should not be struck with a metal hammer. If a chisel has no hoop and its maker does not say it may be struck with steel, use a mallet.
Which mallet for which job
| Task | Mallet | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Chopping dovetails | Lighter joiner’s mallet | Controlled blows at a knife line |
| Chopping mortises in hard wood | Heavier joiner’s mallet | More energy per blow for a deep, narrow cut |
| Carving | Carver’s mallet | Lands the same way at any rotation |
| Assembling or dismantling joints | Soft-faced mallet, or a leather face | Will not mark the work |
| Paring | No mallet | Paring chisels are pushed by hand |
What not to strike
- Paring chisels. They are made to be pushed; Narex states that its paring chisels are not meant to be struck.
- A Western chisel with a metal hammer, unless its maker says it may be. Use a wooden, leather or urethane face. Hooped Japanese striking chisels are the exception described above.
- Damaged tools. OSHA lists loose or splintered handles and mushroomed heads on struck tools as hazards: the head can fly off or shatter. Replace or repair them before striking.
This page is about choosing and using a mallet rather than making one. For chopping technique, see how to use a chisel; for the heaviest chopping, the mortise chisel guide.
Sources
Weights and materials are the makers’ published specifications for particular mallets, given as examples; other mallets differ.
- 1.
Christopher Schwarz. Blue Spruce Joiner’s Mallets. Popular Woodworking.
Used for: Striking faces angled so the full face meets the tool and the work.
- 2.
Rectangular Mallet. Blue Spruce Toolworks.
Used for: One maker’s joiner’s mallets: 14–16 oz and 22–24 oz, resin-infused maple heads, a harness-leather face, and uses for each size.
- 3.
A Little Friendly Persuasion. Blue Spruce Toolworks.
Used for: A leather face for assembling joinery without marking the wood and for softer blows on chisels; a heavier mallet for wide mortises and hard woods.
- 4.
Wood is Good 20 oz Wood Carving Mallet. Wood is Good, as listed by Hardwick & Sons.
Used for: A round urethane-headed carving mallet whose head spreads the load on tool handles; 12, 18, 20 and 30 oz sizes.
- 5.
1/2" Bevel Edge Socket Chisel. Lie-Nielsen Toolworks.
Used for: Chisels not to be struck with a metal hammer.
- 6.
Narex Imperial Paring Chisels. Narex, as listed by Infinity Tools.
Used for: Paring chisels are not meant to be struck with a mallet.
- 7.
Stan Covington. Hammers to Use With Chisels Part 1 – Hammer Varieties. Covington & Sons, 2020.
Used for: Japanese chisels struck with a steel gennou; the argument that a steel hammer delivers energy more controllably; wooden mallets as acceptable but not necessary; steel hammers destroying poorly designed Western handles.
- 8.
Stan Covington. The Varieties of Japanese Chisels Part 1: The Main Categories. Covington & Sons, 2019.
Used for: The katsura hoop taking the force of hammer blows and preventing the handle from splitting.
- 9.
Hand and Power Tools (OSHA 3080). Occupational Safety and Health Administration, 2002.
Used for: Loose or splintered handles and mushroomed heads on struck tools as hazards.
About this guide
Written by BenchRoot Editorial. How BenchRoot sources, checks and corrects its pages is set out in the Editorial Policy. If something here is wrong or unclear, the contact page explains how to tell us.
